These words echoed through my head again yesterday: Traduttore traditore… This phrase has been used to suggest that the translator is, by nature, a traitor. Two-faced, hiding behind the writer, a character-free zone, a traitor or turncoat, but one with the power to erase certain connotations or even entire levels of meaning when translating from source to target language. It enables him to create his own text, which is either slightly or blatantly different. Wars have broken out over wrongly translated statements. No kidding. But translations are unavoidable. And so are translators. Especially for the writer who goes unheard in his own language.
Words are not worth the paper they are printed on when they do not find a hearing. On Thursday Roberto Saviano, author of the widely praised Gomorrah, was conspicuous by his glaring absence from the Crossing Border festival. Since his novel about the mafia was published, the man has been at the receiving end of death threats. Translations have greatly boosted his readership and his star has risen to the extent that he has become a big target for gunmen. This serves to remind us that the battle is not nearly over yet, that the fundamental right to expression is often mere rhetoric, likely to be blown away by a November gale if we are not allowed to make the most of it. Allowed is a deliberate choice here, given that it implies a need for permission from the invisible yet ubiquitous spy who watches over the writer’s hunched shoulders and who, while shaking his head, frowning, clacking his tongue, and heckling and harassing, pronounces his judgment. Rapped over the knuckles like a child who has coloured outside the lines. Put your finger to your lips, yes, that’s it, be quiet now, sst, shut up if you want to be my friend. But a writer needs this false friendship, this pretend comradeship like a hole in the head, because he is always in search of readers, allies in critical spirit, minds where his words are safe. And free.
I remember an interview a few months ago with Rafik Lahlou, one of Morocco’s most powerful and wealthiest journalists. He asked me which Moroccan author I thought was worth reading. Without beating about the bush and with the naivety and enthusiasm of a child I replied: “Ben Jelloun. Obviously.” He froze instantly, his mouth narrowed to a disapproving, thin line, he looked about him in exasperation and muttered incoherently and with fluttering eyelids: “You think so? Really? But he’s so controversial.” Still smiling, I replied that I like a bit of controversy. Before I knew it, he had walked through the hotel’s revolving doors and disappeared down the whirling mass of Casa’s streets. That Ben Jelloun has more political enemies than friends and that many officials fear his sharp pen, I already knew. That he could not care less about their antagonism – likewise.
When a word moves beyond mere rhetoric and turns into an opinion which, when aired, acquires a certain power, it begins to take on a life of its own. Literature is powerful, part of our culture and capable of reflecting our own or some other society. Revolutions that have altered the course of history have always sprung from an idea, a thought in somebody’s mind, which found its way out because imprisonment in that head could have lead to explosions and short circuits. When Writers with an Opinion present a Book (yup – all capitals), then I suggest you keep silent and listen or read. We are neither deaf nor illiterate. The last thing we should do is pretend that we are.